E Point Perfect – Interesting and beneficial content

Housing affordability: What happens when lower home prices take on higher borrowing costs?


The following table represents two scenarios: home owners with a 10% down payment, and those with a 20% down payment. Mortgages with a 20% down payment generally have higher interest rates because they are not eligible for mortgage default insurance. However, a home owner who puts down less than 20% will have to account for the added insurance costs. 

Thanks to Gina Athanasious, a RE/MAX real estate expert, for her help with the following calculations. 

(with average home price)
5-year fixed
(10% down)
5-year fixed
(20% down)
5-year variable
(10% down)
5-year variable
(20% down)
Rate Payment Rate Payment Rate Payment Rate Payment
2.59% $3,326 2.79% $3,022 0.90% $2,736 1.25% $2,536
4.79% $3,414 5.04% $3,110 2.50% $2,685 2.80% $2,467
4.34% $3,100 4.59% $2,827 3.50% $2,838 3.85% $2,619

The scorecard shows that, from February to June, variable-rate costs improved modestly, with falling home prices outweighing higher interest rates. Redo the same calculations for the 2022 period of February to July, however, and we see that variable-rate costs worsened, with higher interest rates now outweighing the drop in home prices. 

The opposite is true for fixed-rate mortgage costs. Those costs worsened between February and June but improved modestly between February and July. That said, head-to-head, variable rates seem to remain the more cost-effective option. 

Factoring in the mortgage stress test

The mortgage stress test, which sets a minimum qualifying rate for new mortgages, requires borrowers to prove they can handle their mortgage payment at the greater of 5.25% or their contract rate plus two percentage points. 

With many variable rates now sitting at just north of 4%, many buyers are having to qualify for a mortgage at 6% or higher, rendering the 5.25% threshold essentially not applicable. And now that fixed mortgage rates have increased by two-thirds in just four months, many people applying for fixed-rate mortgages are facing stress-tested rates of around 7%, on average. 

This, too, is putting downward pressure on the housing market. 

James Laird, co-CEO of Ratehub Inc. and president of the mortgage lender CanWise (which is also owned by Ratehub Inc.), explains that generally, for every 1% that the stress test increases, a household qualifies for about 10% less mortgage. “Home prices will need to drop significantly in order to neutralize the effects that higher mortgage rates have on the stress test,” Laird shared in a statement. “Unless this happens, home affordability will continue to be impacted significantly by the current rising rate environment.” 


Source link

Related posts

Compare the best savings accounts in Canada for 2023

Making sense of the markets this week: July 17

How might inflation impact your retirement plans?

How to start investing with ETFs in your 20s

TFSA vs RRSP: How to decide between the two

Watch: How to open a bank account